Scott Bradley: ‘Should We Try To Legislate Morality?’


Source:Freedoms Rising Sun– Moot question

Source:The New Democrat

To answer Scott Bradley’s question: no we should not try to legislate morality. At least when it comes to personal behavior and how free adults conduct themselves in their personal lives.


Source:Merion West– Americans, protesting against alcohol prohibition

It’s sort of a moot question anyway because every civilized country in the world with a functioning government whether it’s a developed country or developing country, legislates morality at least in the sense that it lays the rules for how people can interact with each other. To put it simply, we’re not allowed to hurt innocent people. We’re not allowed to rape each other, physically attack each other, steal from each other murder each other, kidnap each other, commit fraud against each other. We’re not allowed to commit these acts and other dangerous acts against innocent people and if we do we face steep legal consequences for doing these things. Which is why we have jails and prisons because we have people who hurt innocent people everyday and have to pay a justifiable price for them.


Source:Faithful Thinkers– Freedom of Religion, but not theocracy

But that’s not my main interest here anyway, because I’m more interested in what government’s role if any is when it comes to how people conduct themselves in their personal lives. I’m not talking about people hurting innocent people, but I’m not talking about who people act and do with their own lives and conduct themselves in their personal lives and how much freedom should we have in our own lives. When people can have sex, what we can eat and drink, smoke, the types of entertainment that we can listen to and watch, what we can do with our own bodies and what we can put into our own bodies.

Government already legislates morality and I think Scott Bradley is at least smart enough understand that at least, if he doesn’t already know that. The real question is to what extent and should we remain liberal democratic republic or not where personal freedom and autonomy is vast, even if some of our personal choices and activities offends others religious and cultural values. Or do we want big government coming in and telling us who we can have sex with, when we can have sex, who we can marry, what we can put into out bodies, do in the privacy of our own homes and tells us this is what moral and what’s not based on some religious and moral code. And even if what we’re doing is not actually hurting anyone, it still has to be illegal, because it’s immoral according some people’s religious and moral values.

And as a Liberal myself I believe it’s not the job of government to try to protect us from ourselves, but to protect innocent people from predators and predatory behavior. And as long as people aren’t hurting innocent people with what they’re doing, government should stay out of the way and allow for free adults to live their own lives and deal with the consequences of their own decisions. Instead of big government coming in and telling us what we should believe and how we should think and this is how we should live our own personal lives.

Scott Bradley: ‘Should We Try To Legislate Morality’

About Rik Schneider

Blogger/writer on a lot of different subjects.
This entry was posted in Freedom of Choice and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.